Ingredients: chicken broth, boneless beef short ribs, kale, tomato paste, garlic, yeast extract spread, pearl barley, soy sauce, celery, canned whole tomato, carrot, bay leaf, onion, canola oil

Ingredients: chicken broth, boneless beef short ribs, kale, tomato paste, garlic, beef shank, bread crumbs, parmesan, heavy cream, short-cut pasta, celery, peppercorn, carrot, vegetable oil, bay leaf, egg, parsley, onion