Ingredients: buttermilk, flour, milk, caramel sauce, shortening, butter, apple, vanilla, egg, cinnamon, confectioners’ sugar, sugar, baking soda

Ingredients: buttermilk, flour, milk, caramel sauce, shortening, chocolate chips, butter, condensed milk, shredded coconut, vanilla, egg, confectioners’ sugar, cocoa, sugar, caramel syrup, baking soda

Ingredients: buttermilk, flour, milk, caramel sauce, shortening, pecan, heavy cream, butter, candy, vanilla, egg, confectioners’ sugar, dutch-process cocoa, sugar, canola oil, dark chocolate chips, baking soda