peanut butter
dark chocolate chips
shortening
vanilla
butter
confectioners’ sugar
egg
flour
brown sugar
sugar
baking soda
peanut
milk
baking powder
cream cheese
rolled oats
peanut butter cups
heavy cream
cocoa
peanut butter chips
white baking chips
rice cereal
vegetable oil
chocolate chips
graham cracker crumbs
dark cocoa
pretzels
sweetened condensed milk
buttermilk
chocolate candy
pie crust
coconut flake
margarine
dutch-process cocoa
almond extract
walnut
butterscotch chips
sour cream
graham cracker
corn syrup
coffee
whipped cream
shredded coconut
banana
quick-cooking oats
cream of tartar
food coloring
canola oil
marshmallow creme
almond
chopped nuts
frosting
unbleached all-purpose flour
chocolate
white chocolate
dark corn syrup
candy corn
candy sprinkles
dark chocolate
cinnamon
marshmallow
peanut-butter sandwich cookies
peanut butter powder
peanut butter cookie mix
peanut butter, dark chocolate chips & shortening recipes

166 recipes

Page 1

Peanut Butter Meltaways Recipe

momfoodie.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, white baking chips

Peanut Butter Meltaways Recipe

momfoodie.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, white baking chips

Tiger Butter Fudge

aroundmyfamilytable.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, white baking chips

Easy Butterfinger Candy

cookitonce.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, candy corn

Chocolate Peanut Butter Grahams

thegratefulgirlcooks.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, graham cracker

Easy Butter Fingers Candy

crecipe.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, candy corn

Gluten And Dairy Free Peanut Butter Cups

spoonacular.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, agave nectar

Fluffernutter Cups

girlversusdough.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, marshmallow creme

Tiger Butter Fudge

realhousemoms.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, white baking chips

Peanut Butter Meltaways Recipe

cincyshopper.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, white baking chips

The Best Peanut Clusters

cookingwithkarli.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, peanut, white baking chips

Christmas Peanut Clusters

twosisterscrafting.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, peanut, candy sprinkles

Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter Ritz Cookies

thegratefulgirlcooks.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, crackers, confectioners’ sugar

Peanut Butter Bon Bons

thegratefulgirlcooks.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, butter, confectioners’ sugar

Nuts-About-You Cookie Sticks

tasteofhome.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, chopped nuts, cookies

Buckeye Balls I

allrecipes.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, butter, confectioners’ sugar

Chubby Hubby Sundae Cones

sugardishme.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, ice-cream cone, pretzels

Easy Buckeye Recipe

spendwithpennies.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, butter, vanilla, confectioners’ sugar

Peanut Butter Buckeyes Recipe

browneyedbaker.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, butter, vanilla, confectioners’ sugar

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

thekitchenismyplayground.com

Ingredients: peanut butter, shortening, dark chocolate chips, butter, vanilla, confectioners’ sugar
peanut butter
dark chocolate chips
shortening
vanilla
butter
confectioners’ sugar
egg
flour
brown sugar
sugar
baking soda
peanut
milk
baking powder
cream cheese