Ingredients: cream cheese, apple pie spice, shortening, cinnamon, sugar, heavy cream, flour, sour cream, butter, caramel extract, baking powder, apple, vanilla, egg, confectioners’ sugar, baking soda

Ingredients: cream cheese, apple pie spice, shortening, cinnamon, sugar, buttermilk, half and half, butter, unbleached all-purpose flour, baking powder, vanilla, egg, allspice, confectioners’ sugar, applesauce, cider, baking soda