Ingredients: worcestershire, beef short ribs, thyme, potato, parmesan, butter, beer, cream, celery, balsamic vinegar, carrot, onion, sugar, canned tomato, garlic

Ingredients: worcestershire, beef short ribs, thyme, potato, beefy onion soup mix, beef roast, flour, celery, garlic powder, red wine, carrot, bay leaf, olive oil, onion, garlic

Ingredients: worcestershire, beef short ribs, thyme, potato, beef broth, milk, butter, celery, balsamic vinegar, paprika, brown sugar, red wine, carrot, bay leaf, parsley, olive oil, cornstarch, onion, garlic